Yokaze no Shiwaza is populer song that came from Team B Theater no Megami. This song always in Request Hour since 2011 till now. This song is very Yukirin image because almost performance song by Yukirin except at some concert and event in AKB48 5 Big Dome Concert Tour she choose this song herself because she like it. Before i talk about Karen version lets talk abot other version
1. Kashiwagi Yuki
Yokaze no Shiwaza Yukirin version is good because she do it many times. Apart from this from this she good played the role and about the voice is good because Yukirin voice characteristic is low voice to normal and its simple voice but because this song actually very low voice there some note that she force to do it it so some harmony its lost, but its still good.
2. Maeda Atsuko
Her version is little bit good, she can almost reach the very low notes (Maeda voice characeristic is low-normal) but she cannot get harmony to this song. About the act is good but less some expression in some point.
3. Itano Tomomi
Her version is not good at all, why? eventhough she is singer in AKB with many singles in this song her voice dont suited and at some point that is weird sound from her voice. She didn`t get role at all and he just sing the song that is cannot work to this song because this song full of story. Her voice characteristic is normal type and not in the way note is so this song become disharmony to hear. I dont blame her because most of singer especially that i analysis in AKB only have one type of comfort note, when she exit from this comfort zone she cannot keep up up with song harmony.
4. Ju JingYi
You wont kon her right? she is SNH48 NII, actually i only listen to her performance but she can perform it very well. Her voice type is normal-low but she sing it with hormonicaly to this song, eventhough the lyric is chinese but the choosen word is suited to the note so not to much change this song.
The last explanation of Karen, this song is kind of solo song that required dominant vocal and act ability to communicate to the audience (almost no dance). Like i tell you before Karen voice is special because is multirange from slow-normal-high that why anything song she sing always good to hear which is veri different for common singer with only one type. Apart from this, the way she perform it very amazing because she can reach the low notes and keep harmony to this song. If you look her act she do it with total action with sad expression from beginning she enter the stage and the way her walk is described how story from this song. Her way of singing and emotion she show make this better. Even if this is only live show but the quality is as good as recording one (very rare type because some of singer is good at recording but in live the singing is different). Some of people said Yukirin is better than Karen but it not just personal taste, if you want to judge how good quality the song is? you must close your eyes, your emotion and open your mind while listen with ear that connect to your heart and yo will know which one is good. If you think it in analogy i can example it if you eat ordinary meat and then eat wagyu you will agree that wagyu is better than ordinary meat. In addition for her voice is very mature for 13 years old girl and her singing always remain in your heart and can make your cry. That why she often become under of Yukirin and Yukirin also said it to other that she feel inferior to Karen singing.
Yokaze no Shiwaza
No comments :
Post a Comment